Location #1: The house
18 Brooks Road, Toms River, New Jersey, United States
Note from the Webmaster: It has been moved since.
Location #2: Church (and the house)
At 406 Forman Avenue, Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey, United States
Location #3: Town Hall
Township of Toms River, 33 Washington Street, Toms River, New Jersey, United States
Location #4: Witches Brew Bar
At 20 West Water Street, Toms River, New Jersey, United States
Note from the Webmaster: At the back.
* A contribution by K. Swartz!
Location #5: Garden
Georgian Court University (the bridge is on North Lake Drive), Lakewood Township, New Jersey, United States
The bar scene in the 1979 Amityville Horror was filmed at a bar on East Water Street in Toms River,NJ. The bar is long since gone and the area has been converted into a park
The Witches Brew bar was actually a bar called “Reynolds”, if I remember correctly. The scene was shot at the rear of the building. It is currently the “Music Academy”, a place for music lessons.
In the background of this shot you can see the roof of a hotel. It is currently called “The Red Carpet Inn”.
That area is on the corner of Water street and Rt. 9, not far from the house used in the movie.
I remember driving past the house, with my parents, as a kid while they were shooting a scene.
Wow, that’s amazing. Thanks so much for the info, as I’ve been trying to find this location for ages!!!